Middlebury is a town in Wyoming County, New York, home to about 1,336 people across 36 square miles. Its ZIP codes are 14039 and 14591, and parts of 14054 and 14569 are in Middlebury too.
Homes sold for a median of $96 per square foot in the three months ending August 2026, a seller’s market.
All in Middlebury
Mostly Middlebury; also Covington and Perry
Mostly Bethany; part is in Middlebury
Mostly Warsaw; part is in Middlebury
Each card is that ZIP code’s whole market, including any part outside Middlebury. Seller’s market: under 4 months of supply; buyer’s market: over 6. Methodology
We’re writing up Middlebury’s story and what everyday life there is like, for people thinking about moving in.
Are you a local agent who knows Middlebury well? Agents who advertise here will be able to write the guide. Advertise on OfferBacked
| Nearest major airport | Frederick Douglass Greater Rochester International Airport (ROC)30 miles away |
|---|---|
| Nearest city of 250,000+ | Buffalo, NY39 miles away |
| Nearest city of 1 million+ | Philadelphia, PA248 miles away |
Straight-line distances from the center of Middlebury; driving is longer.
Source: Airports from OurAirports (scheduled passenger service); city centers and populations from the U.S. Census Bureau.
Source: Members of Congress from the congress-legislators project; districts from the Census Bureau’s relationship files; governor and mayor from Wikidata.
Middlebury had 1,339 residents in the 2020 census, down 11% since 2000.
It’s the 802nd largest of 1,007 towns in New York by population.
Wyoming County grew from 30,413 residents in 1900 to 40,531 in 2020.
Wyoming County, 1900–2020
Source: U.S. Census Bureau decennial censuses (counties 1900–1990 from the Bureau’s historical county file).
Average highs peak around 77°F in summer, and winter lows average 15°F. About 41.9 inches of rain and melted snow fall in a typical year.
Source: NOAA 1991–2020 climate normals, Wyoming 3w, NY weather station (2 miles away).
8,051 jobs at 754 businesses in Wyoming County. The biggest industries by employees:
Source: U.S. Census Bureau County Business Patterns 2023 (private employers; jobs counted where people work).
3 doctors and other health care providers list an office in Middlebury’s ZIP codes.
Nearest hospitals
Providers with an office here
| Nurse practitioners and physician assistants | 1 |
|---|---|
| Mental health providers | 1 |
| Physical and occupational therapists | 1 |
Source: Hospitals from CMS Hospital General Information (ratings are CMS overall star ratings); straight-line distances; providers from the CMS National Plan and Provider Enumeration System (NPPES), by practice address and primary specialty.
Parks (2 nearby)
Grocery stores
Libraries (1 nearby)
Counts are within about 4 miles of the center of town.
Source: Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors (openstreetmap.org/copyright), as mapped by volunteers; it can miss places or include closed ones.
Public schools here are run by Wyoming Central School District. Check each district’s attendance zones for a specific address.
| School | Grades | Students | Type | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wyoming Central SchoolWyoming | Pre-K–8 | 151 | Public | 0.6 mi |
Source: U.S. Department of Education, NCES: Common Core of Data (2024-2025) for public schools. Listed by address; we don’t rate schools.
Buying or selling around Middlebury? Tell us what you need and when. No agents advertise here yet, so we’ll keep your request for up to 30 days and send it to local agents who join. No obligation, and you choose who to work with.
Loading map…
Shares ZIP codes with Warsaw, Bethany, Attica, Orangeville, Covington, Gainesville, Perry, Wethersfield, Pavilion and Stafford.
Town boundaries don’t always match ZIP codes: a ZIP code can cross into neighboring towns, and a town can share a ZIP code with its neighbors. Facts describe the town itself; market figures describe whole ZIP codes.