Is Kelleys Island, OH 43438 a buyer’s or seller’s market?

Balanced 3 months ending August 31, 2026 · Source: Redfin

Kelleys Island is a balanced market. With about 4.8 months of supply, well-priced homes can still draw more than one offer, but buyers have some room to negotiate.

Months of supply4.8Under 4 months = seller’s market

Sold above original list0%Share of sales, last 3 months

Median sale-to-list94.7%Sold price ÷ list price

Median days on market82Listing to accepted offer

Median price per sq ft$427▲ +33.8% vs. last year

Run the numbers for 43438

Prefilled for 43438Can I win this house?Multiple-offer likelihood for a listing Prefilled for 43438Over-asking calculatorTypical range over list ToolOffer strength scoreHow your offer looks to a seller ToolAppraisal gapCash needed if it appraises low

Nearby markets

Berlin Heights 44814Seller’s market $143 /sq ft Castalia 44824Balanced $177 /sq ft Huron 44839Seller’s market $184 /sq ft Milan 44846Seller’s market $180 /sq ft Browse all markets →

Local agents

See all agents in 43438 →

No sponsored agents in 43438 yet. Are you an agent here? Put your name in front of local buyers.

More tools for 43438

Competition score Buyer leverage Negotiation room Compare with other ZIP codes True cost to buy Property taxes Closing costs Cash buyers Backup offer odds Home value Erie County property taxes Erie County loan limits Closing costs in Ohio Hottest ZIP codes in Ohio

Market data describes housing activity only. Figures are rolling 3-month values from Redfin and may be revised. Methodology